Crafty by Numbers Review 2026: Beautiful Paint-by-Numbers Kits Undermined by Shipping and Support Nightmares

Introduction

Crafty by Numbers sells a simple promise: a pre-printed canvas, numbered paint pots, and brushes that let anyone create a piece of art without years of practice. The brand has built a following with a catalogue of over 500 designs, custom photo-to-canvas kits, and a 4.7/5 rating from more than 1,500 reviews on its own website. For anyone looking for a relaxing, screen-free hobby or a thoughtful gift, the appeal is obvious.

But the ownership experience is a story of two very different companies. On its own site, reviewers describe therapeutic evenings, vibrant colours, and finished pieces they are proud to hang. On independent platforms like Trustpilot and Thingtesting, the narrative is one of missing deliveries, poor-quality canvases, unresponsive customer service, and a return policy that offers no way out once an order is placed. This review separates the genuine creative appeal of the kits from the fulfilment, quality, and support problems so you can decide whether Crafty by Numbers is worth the risk.

What Is Crafty by Numbers?

Crafty by Numbers is an online retailer of paint-by-numbers kits for adults and children, operating through its own Shopify-based store at Crafty by Numbers. The company is registered at 2093 Philadelphia Pike, Claymont, Delaware, and it sells a wide range of pre-designed kits, custom photo-to-canvas orders, and starter sets.

Key aspects of the brand include:

• Product focus: paint-by-numbers kits with pre-printed numbered linen canvas, numbered acrylic paints, and brushes
• Catalogue size: hundreds of designs across landscapes, animals, florals, and custom photo conversions
• Pricing: typically around $39.00 for a standard kit, with framed options and custom kits costing more
• Returns and cancellations: the brand’s policy states there are no cancellations or returns once an order is placed, a point that reviewers repeatedly criticise
• Customer support: handled via email at sales@craftybynumbers.com and support@craftybynumbers.com, with reviewers describing long delays and generic replies
• Shipping: orders are processed Monday to Friday, with delivery times that reviewers describe as slow and often longer than advertised

The brand’s identity is built on accessible creativity and a large design library rather than on reliable logistics or consumer-friendly policies.

The Product Line: Pre-Designed Kits and Custom Canvases

Crafty by Numbers catalogue is broad, and the differences between product types matter because quality and customer satisfaction vary across lines.

Pre-Designed Kits are the core of the business. Standard kits include a numbered linen canvas, numbered acrylic paints, three brushes, a colour card, and a reference sheet. Popular designs include landscapes like Seasons in Bloom – Japanese Garden Path and Forest in Autumn, both priced at $39.00.

Custom Photo-to-Canvas Kits allow buyers to upload a personal photo that is converted into a numbered canvas with matching paints. These are positioned as personalised gifts, but reviewers note that the final result can look different from the original photo because of the colour-matching process.

Starter and Beginner Kits are marketed as 20–40 minute mindful sessions with pre-mixed paints and clear numbered sections, designed for people with no painting experience.

Framed Options add a frame to the canvas, and reviewers who chose framed kits generally report better results than those who received rolled canvases.

Build Quality and Materials: Inconsistent Canvases and Paints

Quality is where the Crafty by Numbers experience splits most sharply, and the evidence suggests that the product you receive depends heavily on the batch and the specific kit.

What positive reviewers praise:

• Many customers describe the paints as “smooth and creamy” with good coverage, and the finished paintings as vibrant and display-worthy.
• Framed kits are consistently better received, with reviewers noting that the numbering is well done and the quality is good.
• Some reviewers describe the process as “therapeutic” and the kits as easy to follow, even for people with no artistic experience.

Where the quality claims break down:

• Canvas quality is inconsistent. One reviewer noted that the first canvas was smooth and easy to paint on, but the next two were “rough” and harder to work with.
• Paints are not always numbered or matched correctly. A reviewer who paid $45 and waited almost a month received paint pods that were “NOT numbered” and had to use a colour chart that did not match the paints.
• Coverage is poor on some kits. A detailed review described “ridiculously bad quality of paint” and noted that even after four layers, the paint was “not covered and extremely uneven”.
• Brushes are described as low quality, with one reviewer noting that the “professional” brushes they paid extra for were not up to the task.

Design and the Painting Experience

The design of the kits is intended to make painting accessible, and for many buyers, the experience delivers on that promise.

What works well:

• The numbered sections and reference sheet make the process straightforward, and reviewers describe it as relaxing and meditative.
• The variety of designs is a genuine strength, with options for every taste and skill level, from simple starter kits to high-detail expert canvases.
• The custom photo option is appealing for personalised gifts, even if the final result can differ from the original image.

Where the design does not work for everyone:

• Numbering can be too small or too dark, making it difficult to cover with paint and requiring extra layers.
• Custom kits can produce results that look different from the original photo, with colours that do not match the reference.
• Difficulty ratings are not always clear, and some buyers find that the detail level is higher than expected for a standard kit.

Performance: Does It Deliver the Promised Experience?

Performance is where the Crafty by Numbers story is most divided, with satisfied hobbyists on one side and frustrated buyers on the other.

What positive reviews suggest:

• Many customers describe the process as “therapeutic” and “relaxing”, with one noting that it got them “off my phone for many hours”.
• Repeat buyers report that the finished paintings look good and that the kits are a fun way to spend an evening.
• Some reviewers describe the paints as high quality and the colours as vibrant, especially on framed kits.

Where performance falls short:

• Shipping is slow and unreliable. One reviewer ordered Christmas kits on November 21 and still had nothing by December 26. Another waited over two months for an order that never arrived.
• Missing deliveries are a recurring complaint, with reviewers describing packages that were never received and support that did not resolve the issue.
• The final result can differ from the product photos, with one reviewer noting that the finished painting “does not look quite as much as the offered artwork” because the colours did not match.

Pricing and Value

Crafty by Numbers’ pricing is mid-range for the paint-by-numbers category, and the value case depends entirely on whether the kit arrives complete and matches expectations.

Typical pricing:

• Standard kits: around $39.00
• Framed kits: higher, but generally better received
• Custom photo kits: premium, with variable results
• Shipping: additional, with expedited options that do not always arrive on time

The value case is strongest for framed kits and standard designs where the quality is consistent, and weakest for custom kits and expedited shipping, where the risk of disappointment or delay is higher.

Customer Experience: The Delivery and Refund Problem

This is the part of the Crafty by Numbers story that any honest review must confront directly. The brand replies to some reviews, but the independent record is dominated by fulfilment and refund complaints.

Trustpilot ratings:

• The main Trustpilot page shows an “Average” rating of around 3 out of 5, with reviewers describing both positive experiences and serious problems.
• Regional pages show scores between 3.1 and 3.3 out of 5, with a 100% response rate to negative reviews on some pages but replies that “typically” take up to a month.

Recurring complaints:

• No cancellations or returns. Reviewers describe the policy as “incredibly consumer unfriendly”, noting that once an order is placed, there is no way to cancel or return it.
• Unresponsive or “fake” customer service. A reviewer noted that “Rose Mary is not a real person” and that support replies are generic and unhelpful.
• Wrong addresses and missing packages. One reviewer reported that their order was sent to the wrong address, with a picture of the wrong house, and that the company blamed the courier and refused a refund.
• Expedited shipping that does not arrive. A reviewer who paid extra for expedited shipping to receive a Valentine’s Day gift was told the package was delayed and that no refund would be issued because shipping is “part of the overall fee”.

Positive experiences do exist:

• Some reviewers describe fast shipping and good communication, particularly for framed kits and orders placed outside peak seasons.
• The brand’s own site shows a 4.7/5 rating from over 1,500 reviews, which suggests that many buyers do receive a product they are happy with.

Pros and Cons

Crafty by Numbers vs. Standard Alternatives

How does Crafty by Numbers compare to other paint-by-numbers brands and marketplace sellers?

Crafty by Numbers’ advantage is the size of its design library and the appeal of custom kits. Marketplace sellers are cheaper but even less reliable, while premium brands offer better support and returns but at a higher price. For a buyer who is willing to accept risk for a specific design, Crafty by Numbers is an option. For a buyer who wants a guaranteed product and support, the alternatives are safer.

Verdict and Final Thoughts

Crafty by Numbers sells a genuinely appealing product. The kits are designed to be accessible, the design library is large, and many buyers describe a relaxing, rewarding experience that ends with a piece of art they are proud to display. For those who receive a good kit and do not need to contact support, the value is real.

But the ownership experience is not reliable. Shipping is slow, missing packages are a recurring complaint, canvas and paint quality vary, and the no-returns policy means that once you order, you are committed. The gap between the 4.7 rating on the brand’s own site and the “Average” or “Poor” ratings on independent platforms is a warning sign that potential buyers should not ignore.

Who is Crafty by Numbers best for?

• Buyers who want a specific design that is not available elsewhere and are prepared to wait
• Anyone who is comfortable with a no-returns policy and will inspect the kit immediately on arrival
• Shoppers who purchase through a payment method with chargeback protection
• People who treat the kit as a low-stakes hobby purchase rather than a guaranteed gift

Who should look elsewhere?

• Buyers who need a reliable delivery date for a gift or event
• Anyone who prioritises responsive customer support and a fair return policy
• Shoppers who want consistent canvas and paint quality
• People who are not comfortable with the risk of a missing or delayed order

Overall, Crafty by Numbers is worth considering only if you go in with realistic expectations and protect your purchase. The designs are appealing and the hobby is genuinely rewarding, but the fulfilment and support experience is not reliable enough to recommend without significant caveats.

Considering Crafty by Numbers? Pay with a credit card or PayPal for chargeback protection, avoid expedited shipping unless you have confirmed it is tracked, and inspect the kit immediately on arrival for missing or damaged items.

Scorecard