Peloton is one of the most coveted exercise bikes, but its price can be a deterrent. In October 2025, Peloton introduced a new version of its popular bike as part of its Cross Training Series. However, several alternatives offer comparable quality and features at more accessible prices. CNET tested each exercise bike through at least 100 miles of riding, using as many built‑in features as possible. The top picks are the NordicTrack S24 Studio Bike (best overall) and the Echelon Connect EX-5S-22 (best easy‑to‑use). This review covers the key specifications, subscription costs, assembly experiences, warranty details and how each bike compares to the Peloton.
NordicTrack S24 Studio Bike: Best Peloton Alternative Overall
The NordicTrack S24 Studio Bike offers a high‑end experience similar to the Peloton with some extra features. It costs 2,399 USD, which is more than a Peloton. The bike includes a 24‑inch touchscreen (larger than Peloton‘s 21.5‑inch screen), a SmartAdjust feature that automatically adjusts resistance based on your fitness level, and the ability to connect to third‑party apps such as Netflix, Prime, Spotify, Strava, Garmin Connect and Google Fit.
| Feature | Specification |
|---|---|
| Dimensions | 56.4 inches long, 21.8 inches wide, 62.7 inches high |
| Max Weight Capacity | 350 pounds |
| Resistance | 24 levels of digital resistance (automatically adjustable) |
| Screen Size | 24 inch touchscreen (swivels for floor exercises) |
| Membership | iFIT (15 USD/month or 144 USD/year) or iFIT Pro (39 USD/month or 396 USD/year) |
| Connectivity | Bluetooth headphones, heart rate monitors, third‑party apps |
| Warranty | 1 year (frame, motor, parts and labour) |
| Price | 2,399 USD |
| Assembly | Included (with purchase) |
Pros
- Quiet and smooth operation.
- Auto‑adjust option adds real‑life feel to workouts (inclines and declines based on terrain).
- Touchscreen is 24 inches (larger than Peloton’s).
- Can connect to popular third‑party apps (Netflix, Spotify, Strava, etc.).
- Individual volume control for instructor and music.
- Built‑in fan.
- Comes with 3‑pound dumbbells and rack.
- Double‑sided pedals (cages for sneakers and clips for cycling shoes).
Cons
- Handlebars have plastic buttons for resistance and incline (look cheap, may break easily).
- iFIT Pro membership costs 39 USD/month (more than Peloton‘s 44 USD/month but required for advanced features).
- Cannot connect to the Peloton app.
- The S24 costs more than a Peloton.
- iFIT instructors do not match Peloton instructors‘ energy.
The SmartAdjust feature is the standout. When cycling through a scenic virtual route, the bike automatically adjusts incline based on elevation. The screen swivels, so you can do floor exercises (yoga, strength training) off the bike while still following the instructor. The bike is best for users who want an immersive experience with auto‑adjusting resistance. It is not for users on a tight budget or those who specifically want Peloton classes.
Echelon Connect EX-5S-22: Best Easy‑To‑Use Peloton Alternative
The Echelon EX-5S-22 is intuitive to use and provides a similar look and experience to the Peloton. It costs 1,099 USD, which is significantly less than the NordicTrack and the Peloton. The bike includes a 22‑inch HD touchscreen, 32 levels of magnetic resistance and access to the Echelon Fit app.
| Feature | Specification |
|---|---|
| Dimensions | 21.25 inches deep, 52.36 inches wide, 56.29 inches high |
| Max Weight Capacity | 300 pounds |
| Resistance | 32 levels of magnetic resistance (manual knob) |
| Screen Size | 22 inch HD touchscreen (does not tilt) |
| Membership | Echelon Premier (40 USD/month, cancel anytime) or FitPass (11.99 USD/month, limited classes) |
| Connectivity | Bluetooth, Strava, Apple Health, Fitbit, Spotify, Apple Music, Audible |
| Warranty | 1 year |
| Price | 1,099 USD |
| Assembly | DIY (instructional video) or paid in‑home assembly (varies by location) |
Pros
- Easy to use (minimal learning curve).
- Screen is 22 inches (larger than Peloton‘s 21.5‑inch screen).
- Quiet when in use.
- Echelon Premier membership is 40 USD/month (cheaper than Peloton’s 44 USD/month).
- Can connect to third‑party apps (Strava, Apple Health, Fitbit, Spotify).
- Pedals are double‑sided (cages and clips).
Cons
- Issues connecting to Bluetooth initially (requires troubleshooting).
- Cannot connect to the Peloton app.
- Classes may be less engaging than Peloton‘s.
- Warranty is only for 1 year.
- Screen does not tilt for floor exercises.
Assembly is similar to BowFlex; you can follow an instructional video or pay extra for in‑home assembly. The Echelon Fit app gives you access to live and on‑demand classes. The bike is best for riders who want a bike that is easy to use and does not require much of a learning curve. It is not for users who want to connect to the Peloton app or who find Peloton instructors highly motivating.
Peloton Alternatives Compared
| Aspect | NordicTrack S24 | Echelon EX-5S-22 | Peloton (Bike) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | 2,399 USD | 1,099 USD | 1,445 USD (approx) |
| Screen Size | 24 inches (swivels) | 22 inches (fixed) | 21.5 inches (rotates) |
| Resistance | 24 levels (auto‑adjust) | 32 levels (manual knob) | 100 levels (manual knob) |
| Membership Cost | iFIT (15 USD/month) or iFIT Pro (39 USD/month) | Echelon Premier (40 USD/month) | Peloton All‑Access (44 USD/month) |
| Max Weight Capacity | 350 lbs | 300 lbs | 297 lbs |
| Warranty | 1 year | 1 year | 5 years (frame), 1 year (components) |
| Assembly | Included | DIY or paid | Included |
| Third‑Party Apps | Yes (Netflix, Spotify, Strava) | Yes (Strava, Spotify, Apple Health) | No |
The NordicTrack has the largest screen and the auto‑adjust feature. The Echelon is the most affordable and has the simplest interface. The Peloton has the best warranty and the most engaging instructors.
Other Bikes Tested (Not Selected)
Schwinn IC 4: The console arrived broken and would not turn on. It does not have a touchscreen, so you need a tablet to follow classes. Not recommended as a Peloton alternative.
ZWIFT Ride with KICKR Core: Designed for serious cyclists who want an indoor trainer experience. No touchscreen; requires a tablet or smartphone to use the ZWIFT app. The workout imagery resembles a video game. Better as an exercise bike than a Peloton alternative.
Horizon 7.0 IC Indoor Cycle: Straightforward and reliable. No touchscreen, lacks high‑tech features. Does have a lifetime warranty. Connects to the Peloton app. Simple, but not the best option.
Factors To Consider When Choosing A Peloton Alternative
Assembly: Peloton assembly is included. For alternatives, check whether assembly is included, DIY or available for an extra fee. Consider how clear the instructions are and how long assembly takes.
Features: Look for a subscription to access classes. Decide whether the membership is essential or if you can just ride without it. Check whether the bike connects to third‑party apps.
Functionality: Examine how well the bike functions compared to a Peloton. Check for broken parts, correct functionality and intuitive controls.
Warranty: Know the warranty length and what parts it covers (frame, motor, parts, labour).
Screen: Decide between a built‑in touchscreen or a BYO (bring your own) tablet. A built‑in screen is more engaging but adds cost.
Subscription: Peloton All‑Access is 44 USD/month. Alternatives offer their own memberships (iFIT, Echelon Premier) at similar or lower prices. You can use any bike independently, but a subscription unlocks the full experience.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Which bike is Peloton‘s biggest competitor?
NordicTrack, BowFlex and Echelon are the most popular and resemble the Peloton the most.
What should I look for when buying an indoor exercise bike?
Consider cost, size, display screen and whether you want to pay for a monthly subscription. If your goal is to simulate the Peloton experience, look for a bike with a large touchscreen and a library of cycling classes.
Is a built‑in screen or a BYO screen better?
A built‑in screen is more engaging and convenient. A BYO screen (using your own tablet) is more affordable but less immersive. It is a personal preference.
